I purchased a premium Gaia subscription on Black Friday. So now have used paid accounts on:
I’ve not yet used Wikiloc or ViewRanger.
But I understand Wikiloc is good for Europe and South America.
I use Komoot for bikepacking and have been very happy with that product. Is it any good for hiking?
In this post I compare offline navigation for the paid subscriptions.
For discovering trails nearby me (Parksville, Vancouver Island) on their websites, I felt Komoot was weakest. AllTrails best, by far.

On the other hand, one problem with AllTrails is displaying too many options. Too many variations in the same hiking area can be confusing. Since there is a lot of user generated content, quality is mixed.
When I decided on a well known, popular hiking area โ Little Qualicum Falls, again AllTrails was by far best at giving me hiking options.
In terms of description, the AllTrails preview graphic video is most useful for me. I make a lot of decisions on which hike to choose based on these preview videos.
Click PLAY or watch an example on YouTube.
So far, AllTrails is by far my favourite of the three.
Next I went to my iPhones.
Logged into all 3 apps, I searched for “Englishman River Falls“. This is one of the most popular and well established hikes nearby. Komoot identified the trail on a map, but didn’t offer a way to SAVE and download.
I did the hike simultaneously using Gaia and AllTrails on two phones. Both worked well at the basic function of navigation.
I won’t use many of the functions, including Lifeline on AllTrails.
IF I want to make a record of any particular hike, I use the free version of the ReLive app. I’ve had a paid subscription in the past, but find the free features enough for my purposes.
Most mornings I take coffee down to Rathtrevor Beach Provincial Park, my favourite walk in the area.
Again,
Johnny Cheng did a deep dive into both apps, concluding that more inexperienced hikers would probably like AllTrails better. That hunters and those going off trail would appreciate the enhanced mapping features of Gaia GPS.

I’ll search for hikes using a number of different sources as AllTrails can be confusing.
Look at the video preview on AllTrails.
Mostly use AllTrails for navigation. And compare with Gaia if there is any confusion.
Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.
Honestly, for the majority of trails I hike I follow signage. And check the free offline Maps.me app to confirm I’m still on popular trails. It’s all I used on the challenging Laugevagur Trail in Iceland, for example, summer 2023.
I don’t mind getting a little lost on trail. ๐









