not recommended – West Highland Way, Scotland

Trip report by site editor Rick McCharles

I flew into Scotland on a Thursday.

Friday I hopped the train directly to what most consider the best multi-day hike in Scotland, the West Highland Way.

… The West Highland Way, from Milngavie to Fort William, a distance of 95 miles … Hills, dense woodland and wildlife make it one of the favourites with hikers from all over the world. …

Scotland Welcomes You

This kind of hyperbole is typical of the WHW.

I was quickly disgruntled.

Swan

Unless you are a Glasweigan bent on bragging rights for walking out the pub door all the way to the top of Ben Nevis, I can’t see any reason to spend a week of your life doing this hike.

Problems:

  • midges (Spring and Summer)
  • • bad weather
  • • many sections walking on roadways
  • • litter
  • • inconsistent signage
  • • inconsistent trail maintenance
  • • too few highlights / km
  • You won’t get lost. The trail is blazed.

    But why spend a week on this route when there are so many better hikes in Scotland? And the world.

    As many guidebooks recommend, I skipped the first two days and started at Balmaha. On the bonnie, bonnie banks of Loch Lomond.

    Loch-Lomond

    That section alongside the lake was OK, especially between Rowardennan and Beinglass Farm. Not one of the great walks of the world, but OK.

    From there to King’s House Hotel was disappointing in many ways.

    But I must admit, the torrential rain from King’s House over Devil’s Staircase was the quintessential Scottish Hill Walking Experience. Even the Scots called it a “heavy rain”. High praise. My most lasting memory.

    old-boot

    Next day the forecast was for clear skies. I hopped a bus at Kinlochleven, giving up on the WHW for good. I wanted good weather to climb Ben Nevis.

    Over the 3 days on the West Highland Way I have only 22 photos worthy of posting. That’s sad.

    I love Scotland. But why is the hiking so unimproved there?

    Why was the first National Park not established until 2002?

    That famed son of Scotland, John Muir, must be rolling in his grave. Authorities are trying to promote a John Muir Way, a 73km coastal walk.

    As Lonely Planet Walking in Scotland says:

    … you can’t help but wonder what Muir would think of a path through two power stations, one of them nuclear …

    He would not be amused.

    Walk the John Muir Trail in California. Not the one in Scotland.

    And don’t make a special trip to hike the West Highland Way. Instead, go to … Spain.

    not so Bravehearted in Scotland – MIDGES

    by site editor Rick McCharles

    Most who have never visited Scotland mainly know the country because of the 1995 Academy-award winning historical action-drama film produced and directed by Mel Gibson, Braveheart.

    Mel-Braveheart

    Scotland was right irked at the time when Mel and crew decided to move most of the movie shoot to … Ireland.

    … Ireland had won by offering a whole basket of measures, including use of the Irish army as extras in battle scenes …

    That’s the official story. But a Scottish bus driver who was working during some of the Scottish shoot told me that Mel and the crew could not work outdoors in Scotland … because of MIDGES.

    What are MIDGES ??

    Click PLAY or watch Scotland’s most ferocious predator on YouTube.

    There’s even a Scottish Midge Forecast website.

    map

    By a terrible coincidence, most of the best hiking in Scotland is in Midge country, the rugged highlands and islands.

    For example, one story out of LP Walking in Scotland from the best coastal hike, Cape Wrath:

    … We lit the stove for a brew but, within a minute, were reduced to futile, flailing anguish as the black clouds of voracious insects swarmed upon us – even into our mouths. …”

    I finally decided to give up on Scotland hiking while attempting the excellent Ring of Steall loop. At the trailhead I saw many of the Scot hikers coming off the trail with mosquito net hats. As you’ll see in the video, I did not have one with me.

    Click PLAY or watch me on YouTube.

    I’m not Bravehearted enough to face the midges.

    They aren’t as bad as the sand flies of western South Island New Zealand, but they are too much for me.

    One survey found that 86% of visitors warn their friends not to visit Scotland during the key summer months of July and August. Actually, Scotland is no problem in the summer, so long as you don’t stop moving. The cities are fine. But I’d warn everyone not to hike Scotland between June and September, unless you are much tougher than I.

    Related:

    midge facts

    How do midges hunt?

    Laugavegur Tour, Iceland

    After many, many hours trying to find a good deal on airfare. And rent-a-car. I finally gave up on trying to hike the island nation this summer.

    I’ll start months in advance next time. And travel off-season.

    Here’s what I missed …

    Landmannalaugar
    Landmannalaugar

    … Arguably the most famous hiking tour in Iceland is the Laugavegur Tour. Traditionally done north to south, the trek begins at a drop off point called Landmannalaugar. This tiny launch pad is a destination in its own right, in fact I would argue that it is the single most beautiful place I have ever been.

    The area consists of one small hut (sleeps 80), a large campground for trekkers, a small building with sinks, toilets and showers, a covered eating area, an old school bus turned store, and the most coveted of all… a large natural hot spring that serves as swimming pool, meeting place, bath, warming room and of course bar. …

    read the trip report on DolomiteSport – Iceland Laugavegur Tour (Aug. 2009)

    Check out the PatitucciPhoto Iceland Trekking Photos for inspiration.

    I’ve not found a good hiking guidebook for this trek, certainly one of the World’s best.

    hiking Jungfrau, Switzerland – day 3

    Trip report by site editor Rick McCharles

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    Jungfrau hike – day 3

    Descending into Lauterbrunnen valley was amazing. It’s (obviously) a valley of waterfalls, the most famous of which is Trummelbach.

    valley

    My goal for the day … and for the past 20yrs or so … was carless, careless Gimmelwald. (Not to be confused with Grindelwald.)

    Gimmelwald

    “… Once a secret bolthole for hikers and adventurers looking to escape the region’s worst tourist excesses, tiny Gimmelwald is seeing a lot more foot traffic these days. But even even increasing crowds can’t diminish the scintillating … Swiss scenery and charm. …”

    The views from there and nearby Mürren are AMAZING.

    mountain-vista

    Sadly, I was too energetic and excited to stay a night or two at Mountain hostel in Gimmelwald. Or at Esther’s Guesthouse next door. I wish I had.

    The weather was perfect yet again so I decided to push on, perhaps climb up to Schilthorn 2970m.

    Guidebooks say the view from this is even better than that from the TOP OF EUROPE … though it’s a much less expensive ride up. Free if you walk up to Schilthorn.

    Piz-Gloria

    You’ve seen Schilthorn. It was used in the James Bond film On Her Majesty’s Secret Service.

    I climbed without my pack up only to the second last station, Brig. What a view!

    Rick-in-Brig

    Then descended quickly so I’d have a chance to make it over the next high pass before nightfall.

    It was a beautiful walk in the late day alpine light.

    Alpine-trail

    I did manage to clear the next pass, Sefinenfurgge, just at dusk. Not having a proper guidebook, it was a big surprise to find these stairs on the other side.

    stairs

    This valley most visitors to the Jungfrau region never see. It’s more precious for being less travelled.

    Click through to see all my photos from day 3

    This is the highlight section of what some call the Alpine Pass Route (20 days):

    Guidebook – Cicerone Alpine Pass Route, Switzerland, Europe – A Trekker’s Guide. Once again, by Kev Reynolds.

    This was my last major hike in the Alps. I headed next to Scotland.

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    hiking Jungfrau, Switzerland – day 2

    Trip report by site editor Rick McCharles

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    Jungfrau hike – day 2

    By coincidence, I was in Grindelwald the same time as the annual Eiger Bike Challenge. In fact, I hung out at the main tent two days running.

    Hikers, the train and the cycle race all climbed from from the valley to Klein Scheidegg.

    train-Jungfrau

    cyclist-Jungfrau

    Most cyclists had to walk some sections. Fitness and ability level was mixed at this race. Certainly I would have been tempted to rent a bike and join in had I had arrived one day earlier.

    walking-the-bike

    My goal. The hotel at Kleine Scheidegg. I remembered the description well from reading The Eiger Sanction 20yrs before. I bought it as an audio download and enjoyed it again on my iPod during this hike.

    Kleine-Scheidegg

    The train from here to Jungfraujoch 3454m “TOP OF EUROPE” is super expensive. I asked several times if there was somehow I could hike up there instead. … Not without ice climbing equipment, unfortunately.

    The short climb up to the glacial moraine was as high as I got, sadly.

    There’s a feature there I’d never seen before. Benches in water where you can rinse your feet. It even has a bubbler.

    hikers-Jungfrau

    bench-in-water

    By nightfall I found a fantastic place to put up my tent, on a cliff edge overlooking the lovely, tranquil Lauterbrunnen valley.

    mountain-vista

    That evening when I was cooking supper an Italian hiker stopped by. He and his fiance were doing a long through hike through the Alps. Had been on the trail for a couple of months.

    see all my photos from day 2

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    BestHike Eiger Sanctioned

    Trip report by site editor Rick McCharles

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    Jungfrau hike – day 1

    After completing the High Route in the Alps, what other destination there could not possibly be a let down?

    Eiger North Face, of course.

    The Eiger Sanction is a 1972 thriller novel by Rodney William Whitaker, written under the pseudonym Trevanian. The story was made into a film directed by and starring Clint Eastwood in 1975.

    Click PLAY or watch the trailer to Eiger Sanction on YouTube.

    youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tFxmcIrJBU

    Travanian (one of my favourite authors) thought the film vapid, by the way. The book is better.

    Actually, because of the movie, the Eiger is more famous than dangerous. Just around the corner is the much more difficult Black Monk face.

    “Dominated by the famous Eiger, Monch and Jungfrau (Ogre, Monk and Virgin) … the Jungfrau Region boasts the highest density of dramatic scenery. …”

    800px-Männlichen01

    Over the next 3 days I hiked left to right across the face of the Eiger.

    It’s a scenic train journey just getting to Interlaken, the “adventure capital” of Europe. Many Jungfrau hikers base themselves out of this busy tourist trap, but I’d recommend you buy provisions at the huge super market across from the station, and catch the next train up to start at Grindelwald.

    Early in my trip a Swiss hiker from Bern had recommended a route, jotting it down in my note book. Since I could not easily get my hands on either of the guidebooks I wanted in Grindelwald …

    The Bernese Alps by Kev Reynolds

    Tour of the Jungfrau Region by Kev Reynolds

    … I decided to follow her suggestion using only tourist brochure maps. It turned out to be excellent.

    I started by walking up to a ski chalet appropriately named “First” … Here’s the vista.

    mountains-from-First

    The Jungfrau region was everything I hoped it would be.

    Eiger

    There are supposed to be 90km of signed hiking trails (and roads) about this resort. Intriguingly, for Switzerland, 48km of those are supposed to be hikeable year round.

    I stayed up high so long that I actually did not get back to my tent until well after dark, getting lost on the way down. I needed my headlamp to find where I had stashed my pack.

    Rick-in-the-Jungfrau

    I tucked into the trees discretely above Grindelwald. “Wild camping” is legal in Switzerland, but it’s best not to draw attention to yourself.

    tent

    all my photos from day 1

    day 1 | 2 | 3

    great U.K. outdoor photos

    Alan (tall-guy) is a photographer from York, England.

    England

    Check out his top 50 as favourited by flickr users. There are many excellent waterfall time release pics. Most are from North Yorkshire.

    Alan’s work was recommended to me by Stuart of the excellent trailspotting blog. Stuart adds:

    Alan’s stomping grounds include most of Yorkshire, Northumberland and the Lake District in Cumbria. All of which are excellent places if you’re looking for hiking spots in England.

    Mt Blanc to Matterhorn – day 7

    Hiking trip report by site editor Rick McCharles. Day 7 of 7.

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info

    Heaven.

    The sky was clear at dawn, again. Matterhorn beckoned.

    tent-and-Matterhorn

    I love these high traverse walks. You have a superb bird’s eye view of the highest peaks on the other side of the valley. But without so much climbing and descending.

    Today I planned on nearly 30km walking to finish this trek above Zermatt. The highlight is views of the most sought after mountaineering peak in Switzerland, Weisshorn.

    mountains

    I left a Summit Stone with St. Bernard, the patron of mountain travellers.

    Summit Stone
    Summit Stone

    He will keep it safe until collected by another High Route walker.

    St-Bernard

    I said farewell to the goats, too. Pretty creatures spending the Summer in this alpine idyll.

    The Europaweg has many, many interesting sections.

    ridge-walk

    I heard it was “closed” at one point. Due to rock slide.

    This is the most dangerous section. Those tunnels (now crushed) were meant to protect walkers from falling stones.

    rock-avalanche

    In the end, I was able to complete the entire route as laid out in Kev Reynold’s guidebook, including the under-the-waterfall section.

    FINALLY, Zermatt. It took me at least 10hrs of walking to get here!

    Zermatt
    Zermatt

    To celebrate completing Rick’s High Route, I toasted the Matterhorn.

    beer-Matterhorn

    Wonderful. Wonderful.

    It’s a wonderful world.

    See the rest of my photos from day 7.

    Or start reading from the beginning of this 7-day journey, a valuable resource if you MIGHT want to do the Haute Route yourself.

    I highly recommend this adventure. You can do it independently as I did. Or sign on with a guide or group. Or … do as another Canadian did. Hire a company to do all the logistics … (booking accommodation, meals, ground transport, etc.) … then hike it independently. This cost about CAD$1500 in his case.

    The best guidebook in English is Chamonix to Zermatt: The Walker’s Haute Route by Kev Reynolds.

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info

    Mt Blanc to Matterhorn – day 6

    Hiking trip report by site editor Rick McCharles. Day 6 of 7.

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info

    Out of bread, as usual, I wanted to stop in the quaint, quiet town of Gruben for supplies.

    Gruben

    There was only one stale loaf of bread left in the small hotel shop. What! This is Europe. The grocery stores are terrible. But you can always get good fresh bread! (subsidized by the National government)

    Turned out that these blokes had tented by the river in town. And then bought up all the bread first thing in the morning.

    U.K. hikers
    U.K. hikers

    Here are manly men, even the 2 wearing skirts. They were the first to pass me on the trail since I started this hike.

    Amongst the 7 friends they were fluent in French, German, Spanish and Italian. Nice.

    We hiked the same day towards a challenging goal, Augstbordpass. It was high. Well above the helicopters.

    above-helicopter

    above-helicopter2

    In fact, Augstbordpass is the last high pass before the Zermatt valley. Many are excited to cross it. I was less so having opted to do the high, long and difficult 31km Europa Way traverse to finish.

    But it was fun to drop down and down towards the valley far, far below.

    Jungen
    Jungen

    A hiker walking the other direction tipped me to the fact that Ibex were posing on the rocks.

    Ibex

    Ibex-horns

    We assumed they’d been staked there by the tourist industry. What a photo op!

    When we finally got to the valley floor, I dashed around like a madman trying to resupply with food. And still catch the bus up the other side to the trailhead. I wanted to get up high so I could start the long traverse to the finish first thing in the morning.

    … the U.K. hikers passed me again! Waving from another bus.

    Blast.

    Pushing hard, I did manage to climb back up to 2300m to greet St. Bernard at dusk.

    St-Bernard-statue

    Kev Reynolds:

    The satue of St Bernard … commemorates the opening of the Europaweg in 1997. This patron Saint of mountain travellers was … Bernard of Menthon, who had spent many years caring for travellers and pilgrims in trouble after crossing the alpine pass named after him…

    Bernard died in the 1080s and was beatified shortly after. In 1923 Pope Pius XI conifrmed St Bernard as patron saint of the alps. …

    I could just see the top of the Matterhorn in the distance.

    sunset-Matterhorn

    The goats were my only companions up there.

    goats-Europa-Weg

    My best tent site of the trip.

    See the rest of my photos from day 6.

    on to day 7

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info

    Mt Blanc to Matterhorn – day 5

    Hiking trip report by site editor Rick McCharles. Day 5 of 7.

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info

    From my ideal tent site it was a pleasant wander down into the valley of Lac de Moiry.

    Lac-Moiry

    At the same time, an American couple hiking the Haute Route were descending from their night at this interesting farm refuge.

    refuge

    We crossed the Lac de Moiry dam at about the same time.

    dam

    And met up at the bus stop on the other side.

    We decided to cheat (again) by skipping the next pass, and bus instead to Zinal. It was an “easy” pass but I was turned off when I saw a car joy riding the switchbacks up that slope. I’ve no desire to hike where there are roads.

    Swiss-valley

    If you ask hikers what impressions they remember of the Alps, early in the conversation they’ll mention the cows and their loud cowbells.

    Swiss-cow

    Everybody loves them. I never got tired of them.

    Famed Hotel Weisshorn disappointed.

    Hotel Weisshorn

    The area around the hotel was under some serious construction. I’m happy I didn’t stay there. The American couple walked on to Bella Tolla cabin.

    I walked from the Hotel to the next high pass. It was easy and interesting, though the typical afternoon rain began again.

    Meidpass
    Meidpass

    Another superb hiking day.

    I had supper on the other side sitting out of the rain near a giant teepee. (Europeans love North American Indian culture.) Then chased some deer away from a spot they liked to sleep upon in the trees and set up my tent.

    About 4AM one of the deer was barking up a storm. Perhaps barking at my tent.

    See the rest of my photos from day 5.

    on to day 6

    day 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | info