should we close Angel’s Landing in Zion?

When I first saw Angel’s Landing from a distance, I wondered how anyone could get up there.

A group exploring Zion in 1916 felt the same way. Frederick Fisher exclaimed, “only an angel could land on it.”

angels.jpg
photo by champy1013

It’s a gain of 1700ft (518m) via Walter’s Wiggles, steep switchbacks blasted into the cliff. This is strenuous hiking, almost scrambling.

Despite the narrow ridge walk at the top, sheer drop-offs on either side, this climb is safe for those experienced in mountain hiking.

But it is not safe for the general public who have too easy access. After the death of 29-year-old Bernadette Vander Meer in August 2006, perhaps more safeguards need be added.

Climb to the top of Angel’s Landing in Zion National Park and you’ll have an incredible view of Zion Canyon and the surrounding cliffs. You’ll also risk a spell of vertigo if you get too near the edge and glance into the void.

In fact, reaching the top of the landing can be unnerving at times as you have to climb up some steep, and narrow, stretches of rock. The Park Service is well aware of the exposure on these sections and has anchored heavy chains into the most precarious spots so you have something to hang onto.

Over the years five people have died in falls from Angel’s Landing. …

National Parks Traveler: Woman Dies in Fall From Angel’s Landing

On our list of the best hikes in the world, Angel’s Landing is the shortest we include. It’s a fantastic experience for a confident hikers. And only a hop, skip and a jump from Zion Narrows, an even better hike.

I say keep Angel’s open — but do a better job of informing “tourists” of the risk.

more photos on flickr tagged “Angel’s Landing”

5 Replies to “should we close Angel’s Landing in Zion?”

  1. I hiked Angels in September of 2004. Heights typically don’t bother me but I will admit I spent about 30 minutes on Scout Lookout before deciding to head over. My friend with me was very supportortive and said she wouldn’t mind if I wanted us to turn back. Part of what was making me hesitant was the image of the 14 year old boy who had fallen off Angels just a few months earlier. I finally got up the nerve and we proceeded out. It wasn’t long before I was glad I did. The view and the overall experience is one that I will never forget. I’ve later learned that of the the three most recent deaths on the trail including the one in June of 07, two of them were because the hikers didn’t take seriously the risks involved. One climbing out on to a ledge off the marked trails and another standing dangerously close to the edge of the cliff when the ground crumbled beneath his feet. A friend who was with him said he was goofing off. Now while both of these deaths are tragic and I do feel bad for the families involved, I don’t believe the trail should be blamed / closed in instances where people decide to act carelessly.

  2. I think the risks should definitely be made more aware. But it should also be known Bernadette VanderMeer was not some random, “tourist” hiker with no experience. Her and her husband loved to hike, they very very experienced. It’s not like she didn’t know what she was doing… It was an accident, and how will never be answered, but she’s missed everyday..

  3. I was not aware that Bernadette was well experienced.

    Like everyone else, I jumped to the conclusion that those who fall are either reckless or careless.

    My apologies.

  4. Ms. V fell August 22nd. The cell phone 911 call was at 6:30 am, 15 minutes before sunrise. She hiked up in the dark? I’m sure the sunrise would be beautiful from the top, but this is not the hike to do in the dark.

Leave a reply to ludocdoc Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.