Hiking Navigation: AllTrails v Gaia v Komoot

I purchased a premium Gaia subscription on Black Friday. So now have used paid accounts on:

I’ve not yet used Wikiloc or ViewRanger.

But I understand Wikiloc is good for Europe and South America.

I use Komoot for bikepacking and have been very happy with that product. Is it any good for hiking?

In this post I compare offline navigation for the paid subscriptions.

For discovering trails nearby me (Parksville, Vancouver Island) on their websites, I felt Komoot was weakest. AllTrails best, by far.

On the other hand, one problem with AllTrails is displaying too many options. Too many variations in the same hiking area can be confusing. Since there is a lot of user generated content, quality is mixed.

When I decided on a well known, popular hiking area โž™ Little Qualicum Falls, again AllTrails was by far best at giving me hiking options.

In terms of description, the AllTrails preview graphic video is most useful for me. I make a lot of decisions on which hike to choose based on these preview videos.

Click PLAY or watch an example on YouTube.

So far, AllTrails is by far my favourite of the three.


Next I went to my iPhones.

Logged into all 3 apps, I searched for “Englishman River Falls“. This is one of the most popular and well established hikes nearby. Komoot identified the trail on a map, but didn’t offer a way to SAVE and download.

I did the hike simultaneously using Gaia and AllTrails on two phones. Both worked well at the basic function of navigation.

I won’t use many of the functions, including Lifeline on AllTrails.

IF I want to make a record of any particular hike, I use the free version of the ReLive app. I’ve had a paid subscription in the past, but find the free features enough for my purposes.


Most mornings I take coffee down to Rathtrevor Beach Provincial Park, my favourite walk in the area.

Again,

Johnny Cheng did a deep dive into both apps, concluding that more inexperienced hikers would probably like AllTrails better. That hunters and those going off trail would appreciate the enhanced mapping features of Gaia GPS.

I’ll search for hikes using a number of different sources as AllTrails can be confusing.

Look at the video preview on AllTrails.

Mostly use AllTrails for navigation. And compare with Gaia if there is any confusion.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Honestly, for the majority of trails I hike I follow signage. And check the free offline Maps.me app to confirm I’m still on popular trails. It’s all I used on the challenging Laugevagur Trail in Iceland, for example, summer 2023.

I don’t mind getting a little lost on trail. ๐Ÿ˜€

Buckskin Gulch / Paria Canyon, Utah & Arizona

Widely considered the best slot canyon hike in the world!

Michael Lanza wrote-up a terrific trip report:

Before long, the walls stand barely more than shoulder-width apart and perhaps a hundred feet tall and the light at the bottom of this slot canyon grows dim.

We downclimb a sturdy wooden ladder installed for getting over a pour-off that drops several feet.

Little or no direct sunlight reaches us now, only the reflected light hitting the tops of these walls and seeping downward. In rare places where the twisting canyon aligns with the sun, the sudden direct sunlight feels intensely hot, especially in contrast to the pleasant coolness of the deep shade filling most of this slot.

The Big OutsideNOT A DULL MOMENT: BACKPACKING BUCKSKIN GULCH AND PARIA CANYON

Click through for more amazing photos.


related – Clever HikerBuckskin Gulch / Paria Canyon, Utah andย Arizona

BestHike loves Banff, Canada

 

A UNESCO World Heritage site, one of the great tourist destinations of the world, most everyone likes the quaint mountain town, Banff, in the Canadian Rockies. Growth is strictly limited by National Park regulations.

Banff … in Alberta’s Rockies, Canada.

… at 1,463 m (4,800 ft), it is the town with the second highest elevation in Canada, the highest being Lake Louise.

It is surrounded by mountains, notably Mount Rundle, Sulphur Mountain, Mount Norquay, and Cascade Mountain; and situated above Bow Falls near the junction of the Bow and Spray Rivers. Banff is located 126 km (78 mi) west of Calgary and 58 km (36 mi) east of Lake Louise …

…. It is a major destination for outdoor sports and features extensive hiking, biking, scrambling and skiing areas within the region. …

More interesting photos tagged Banff.

Canmore is a smaller town (pop. 12,000) just outside the park, a great alternative to touristy Banff. Alpine Club of Canada headquarters are located in Canmore. Many experienced hikers prefer it as a home base.

Two of our top 10 hikes in the world can be reached from here:

#5) Sunshine to Assiniboine, Alberta, Canada
#6) Glacier North Circle, Montana, USA

Mt. Assiniboine

More interesting photos tagged Assiniboine.

Many Glacier Hotel

More interesting photos tagged Glacier National Park.

Of course there are dozens of “best hikes” in the Rockies.

Lake O’Hara, for example, is the prettiest mountain hiking in the Rockies.

Plan for July to mid-September in the northern Rockies. Banff is a great town, but the hiking season is short. Blizzards are not uncommon in September. We often suggest Aug. 1st as a good start date for a walking holiday here.

Disclosure: besthike is based out of Calgary. Banff is our backyard playground. You could certainly accuse us of bias.
๐Ÿ˜€

BestHike editor Rick McCharles spends a week or so each Spring hiking and skiing. The trails are near empty โ€”ย though you might want to wear spiked shoes.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

RAIN in the Philippines

I’ve mostly been very lucky with the weather over 4 months in S.E. Asia and Taiwan.

BUT it’s rained every day since I got to Palawan island.

A.I. enhanced photo. No actual lightning at the waterfall.

They have frequent earthquakes, cyclones, and volcanic eruptions here. Who knew? ๐Ÿ˜€

The dry season in the Philippines generally runs from December to May. ย 

But 2025 has been wetter than normal. I spoke with one tour guide with a group of Romanian tourists who’s had to change plans most days for the past 2 weeks.

Many tours, especially those by boat, are cancelled by government order.

I started a day hike to Pamuayanย Falls out of Port Barton in good weather. The rain pounded down for perhaps 20 minutes. Then cleared up again.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

That mud was like quicksand.

Mt. Qixing Mountain, Taiwan

Trip report by BestHike editor Rick McCharles

Qixing Mountain (also Cising) stands as the highest and most central peak in Yangmingshan National Park.

All trails are well-maintained with stone steps and converge at the windswept main peak.

The summit is the ultimate reward, offering a magnificent 360-degree panorama of the entire national park, the Taipei cityscape, and the northern coast on clear days.

The national park is known for its cherry blossoms,ย hot springs, sulfur deposits,ย fumaroles, venomous snakes, and hiking trails, including Taiwan’s tallest dormantย volcano,ย Qixing (Seven Star) Mountainย rising to 1,120ย m (3,675ย ft).ย 

There are several Visitors Centres, each very helpful in helping you decide on hikes โž™ starting and finishing. Public transportation is super crowded here.

As you can see, clouds covered the peak when I was there. Not unusual.

Stone steps keep you out of the mud in most cases. But they are irregular shapes and sizes.

The summit is often crowded. I didn’t linger long.

Actually, I enjoyed the clouds blowing in and out, sometimes revealing the vista below.

It can get windy up here, of course

Volcanic sediments in this pond give it a milky appearance.

I finished near Lengshuikeng Hot Springs and would love to have finished with a soak. But these Springs have unusual opening hours. Locked when I was there. AND I was worried about getting back to Taipei on the busy tourist buses.

So I simply soaked my feet in the outdoor pothole.

All-in-all, it’s well worth getting out to Yangmingshan National Park if you are ever in Taipei.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.


5 Deaths Hiking Paine National Park, Chile

Cristina Calvillo Tovar, 37, and Julian Garcia Pimentel, 36 โ€” Nadine Lichey, 45, and Andreas von Pein, 52 โ€”ย and Victoria Bond, 40.

Could these deaths have been avoided?

… On November 16, the weather was mild, and the usual number of hikers, 40 or 50, crossed the pass without incident. By that evening, those who would suffer the worst of the storm had converged at Los Perros campsite, the last sheltered refuge before the exposed John Garner Pass. …

On November 17 between 5 to 7 am, about 30 hikers left Los Perros for John Garner Pass.

Conditions started drizzly, but deteriorated rapidly after 10 am. Winds reached 193kph, and visibility dropped to less than three meters. The temperature fell to โˆ’5 ยฐC, but the wind chill was far below -20ยฐC. …

Those who turned back barely made it down safely. …

A distress post appeared on the Torres del Paineย Facebook groupย around 2 to 3 pm. Initial response by CONAF was slow, and bad weather grounded the helicopters. …

Twenty-seven hikers required medical attention, according to the final tally released by the Regional Government of Magallanes on November 20. …

The Torres del Paine Tragedy: What Really Happened

Image via Global Trend Todayย – likely not from the actual helicopter rescue

Learn more โž™ Paine Circuit

Elephant Mountain, Taipei

Trip report by BestHike editor Rick McCharles

Many tourists visiting Taipei, Taiwan climb short, steep Elephant Mountain to get a great view of the city, including landmark Taipei 101 โ€”ย a building 101 stories high.

  • 1.1 km
  • 141m elevation gain on well maintained stone steps
  • normally very crowded at all hours of the day and evening

Best is to climb up one trail, descend on another. There are many options. So many, in fact, that the signage gets confusing. Use a phone app like AllTrails.

I climbed Elephant mountain twice while in Taipei. It’s easy access from a subway station.

BestHike – Harder Ridge, Switzerland

One of our top 10 day hikes in the world.

photo – AlpsInsight

Why?

24km total … about 18km on a sharp ridge! Wow!

  • Yes, this is our pick for the very best day hike on Earth
  • Brienz to Interlaken Brienz Rothorn Railway up to the start
  • take the funicular from Harderkulm (Harder Kulm)  down to Harderkulm Station in Interlaken
  • logistics are much more difficult in the opposite direction. We highly recommend hikers start in Brienz
  • 10+ hours. Physically and psychologically challenging.
  • no water available. Carry all you need.
  • not an official trail, but it’s easy to follow in good visibility
  • about 1500m above the lake
  • permits not required
  • it’s popular with trail runners who do about 35km entirely on foot. They start at either end.
  • also known as Hardergrat (… grat is ridge in German)

World โ†’ Europe โ†’ Alps โ†’ Switzerland โ†’ Harder Ridge

Click PLAY or watch Jackson Groves on YouTube.

For details click over to our Harder Ridge information page.

related – The GoPro: ’22 Creator Summit was held in Interlaken. Some of this footage is shot on the ridge.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Here’s a graphic representation of the ridge walk, though in the opposite direction from what we recommend.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

El Camino de Costa Rica 280 km

El Camino de Costa Rica is a breathtaking 280 km / 174 mile hike from the Atlantic to the Pacific Ocean, which is no easy feat even for the most experienced hikers.

While it can be intimidating to take on this type of adventure, there are so many incredible things to see and do while trekking this route, from tropical beaches and dense trails to mountain villages and indigenous communities.

official website

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

BestHike โž™ Everest Base Camp / 3 Passes, Nepal

As I post in November 2025, it’s NOT required to hire a guide for this part of Nepal.

Who knows how long it will remain an independent hike? ๐Ÿ˜€


The Everest Base Camp via 3 Passes is one of our top 10 hikes in the world.

Click PLAY or watch a 1 minute introduction on YouTube.

Base Camp / 3 Passes

Everyone wants to hike to Everest Base Camp (5,320m / 17,450ft). The 3 Passes route is the most epic.

Based on weather and fitness, you can do one or more passes as well as peaks like Kala Pattar (5,545m) that don’t require a permit.

base camp sign

AT A GLANCE

Nepal
  • majority of hikers in the Everest region hire a guide, porter(s) and/or pack animal(s) but it’s fairly easy to do independently.
  • guided trekkers stay in lodges, or sprawling tent encampments
  • October to November best months
  • beginning of March to mid-May next best
  • 16-18 days minimum for 3 Passes. 21 days would allow for rest / illness / sidetrip / and other unanticipated delays.
  • if you don’t have time, it’s recommended 14 days just to get to Base Camp and back safely.
  • generally easy hiking on good trails with a light pack. Some very challenging, potentially dangerous sections, if you cross any of the 3 Passes
  • on the main trails buy food as you go and stay in simple “lodges”
  • Everest trails are not expensive, but many spend more than they anticipate on luxuries
  • be clear โ€” you might have to QUIT if by bad luck or rushed ascent you suffer altitude sickness (Acute Mountain Sickness or AMS).
  • many suffer respiratory problems. And fatigue.

Read more on our Everest Base Camp / 3 Passes information page.